Sunday, October 26, 2008

Patriotism and Respect

Students at BYU come from many different countries, and often you can tell if someone is from the United States or not rather quickly. I love the diversity of my school - it is wonderful to be a part of a global community, and even nicer when some neighbors from other countries are nearby so as to be able to learn from them. I lived in another country as a young child, and while I was there, I was taught to be patriotic toward my own homeland and to be respectful of other nations.

I enjoy being on campus near the flag in the evening when it is ceremonially lowered. A fanfare is played prior to a recording of the national anthem being played as the flag is lowered. If you've been there once for it, there is no question what is about to happen. If you haven't, you hear the anthem begin, and should have a fairly good idea that it's time to be respectful and perhaps even somewhat reverent. Loudspeakers project the sound all over campus, so if you're south of the flagpole, chances are that you will hear The Star Spangled Banner either directly or reflected of the side of some buildings. If I can see the flag and I have time, I watch as two ROTC members finish removing the flag from the flagpole and carefully fold the symbol of our nation's unity and liberty.

Wherever I may be when this nightly rite occurs, I pause when I hear those familiar sounds. I often reflect on what it has taken to obtain and to maintain the liberties that I enjoy. The fact that I'm blogging means that I enjoy freedom of the press. I am the man that I am because of the freedoms I have been endowed with - out of no particular valor on my part. Others fought and bled and died for me, and do so now. This is somewhat humbling to me. As this is my country, I place my hand over my heart when I hear the national anthem play, whether or not I can see Old Glory. I do this out of respect for and love of country. I would hope that everyone on campus within hearing of the sounds of this meaningful anthem would stop in respect (if not love). Sadly, reality is quite different.

On Thursday, as I left campus to return home for the evening, I was a few hundred feet from the flagpole when it came time to lower the flag. This particular evening, I knew I did not have time to stay to watch the flag be folded, for which I was sad, but I knew that as a matter of character, I must always make the time to be respectful and show some small measure of patriotism. So I stopped and placed my hand over my heart to watch as the flag was lowered.

I stood there, in my private reverie, and, as usually seems to occur, a few people on their cell phones, having conversations on their mobile phones about dinner, or what movie to watch, or where to go that evening, continued their conversations, and pretended to be oblivious as to what they were walking by and the anthem they ignored as they yelled above it into their phones. I assume from their accents and speech that they were from the United States. I was greatly saddened by this behavior.

If you are from this country, when the national anthem is played, you should at least stop. I find it meaningful to place my hand on my heart, as I have already stated; I hope you do too! If you are from another nation, I hope you will pause out of respect. I would be surprised to see an individual from another nation place her hand over her heart during my country's national anthem, as I do not expect this.

I am very disgruntled with the egocentricity of my generation! You are not so important that you should interrupt someone else's devotion to country. Stand quietly, if nothing else! But really, tell the person on the phone that you need to call him back in a minute, hang up the phone, and take a minute to remember what has happened so that you have the right to be so disrespectful to your country. Take a moment to remember that you stand on soil that has been cleansed by the blood of innocents, of the brave, of the courageous, of those that loved liberty - for all mankind - more than they valued their own lives! And please, remember, these men and women were people just like you; they had friends, family, social interactions, personal pleasures, things they wanted to do with their lives, perhaps dreams of growing old, rocking their children to sleep, bouncing grandchildren on their knees, watching their spouses become more beautiful and wrinkled with time... Get the point? It was no small sacrifice. Consider those that survived Valley Forge. They lost body parts, if not their lives - and you don't grow back you're toes, in case you were too busy texting in biology to learn.

Has our generation lost so much patriotism? Have you? (I don't suppose anyone in the group that I expect will read this would answer yes to the second question - national issues are a constant issue of discussion among these people who have taught me so much.) I am glad to know that so many of my generation are very patriotic.

So many folks are enlisting in the armed forces. People begin to educate themselves about politics. I don't care so much if I agree with you - your particular point of view may drive me bonkers! But if you've really thought about this, have some personal burning toward the way you are going to vote, and you do it (vote!), I can respect you for fulfilling your civil duty to take a moment to direct your government. I find that patriotic in its own very real way.

Just pressing the straight ticket button (I can't believe they even offer that!) seems lazy, inappreciative (and therefore unpatriotic), and foolish. If you vote straight ticket by looking at each issue, great! But please, think for yourself. Talk with people, debate (heatedly even), strengthen your personal convictions - if you don't have them get them by participating in this process, learn, teach, and think critically, passionately, and compassionately. Encourage others to do the same. If we all do this, we can regain our country from the politicians.

James Madison would turn over in his grave at the strength of factions in our country. Do you blindly let them rule your life? If so, if you think your party with its consistent inconsistency is always right, I submit that your patriotism could use a tune up. Parties change - the dems and repubs have nearly switched roles in the last 100 years. They can't always be right. They try to occupy extremes, and really, how often are extremes correct? Rarely, if ever.

What are your thoughts on the flag issue? On patriotism? On my views on patriotism? Is there something I have expressed that seems too extreme? (Self-checking is always good!)

7 comments:

Sea_Gal said...

This post was a fun read. I am thankful that Bishop salmon taught uss reverence for the flag and National Anthem. My heart is always stired when I hear it.
I liked your perspective and the hollowed and sacred ground we live on. I don't think about that enough. I like voting too. It feels meaningful. I don't think we can justify apathy about politic considering what has gone into our right to particpate in thme. Anyway good post my love.

Tommy Dee said...

This post brought a genuine gasp at first...and then a proud sigh... followed by an ear-to-ear smile. The author and I share many beliefs and differ on many many more! But to hear MY heart's words so eloquently expressed by a man who happens to be my son made my heart swell!
To those born here in "the land of the free and the home of the brave"...please know you ARE the first, and DARE to be the second, so the first can remain.
To those who braved whatever they had to in order to "get here", WELCOME to OUR country, mine by birth, yours by choice. Please know you are free now, but freedom is by no means free. Learn OUR language (revere yours, certainly, but learn OURS...it is ENGLISH). To those who cater so blindly to factions, WAKE UP! I HAVE NO DESIRE TO "PRESS 1 for English"... let our newfound neighbors press 1,2,3 etc for their native tongue until they can learn ours. To those newcomers from other lands, please TEACH me all about the traditions of your homeland...but DO NOT denigrate the traditions of MINE! Yes...there IS a basic AMERICAN culture...and it includes such things as an over-commercialized CHRISTMAS (where many Americans have to be reminded that Santa Claus is NOT what Christmas is about...now in the same breath, I say to all my friends with religious fervor...Santa Claus IS part of that AMERICAN tradition... and so is that Christmas tree they took down at the Seattle airport last year so our "friends from other background would not be offended!"
I must say this...out loud and proudly, once and for all to hear... If you're offended by our AMERICAN traditions...GO HOME! Or, better still...enjoy your traditional and native celebrations in your home...but do NOT force them on US! Invite us... we're a nation proud to share...and to learn. But those same kids who laid down their lives since Valley Forge...and well beyond...fought to PRESERVE what our own government now is all too willing to forego. I speak more than one language...and have been in several foreign countries. Their cultures and traditions were very very beautiful to me...and fascinating, and yes... we CAN learn much from SOME of our neighbors. But...while I was in those countries, I did my best to RESPECT their traditions, and still honor my own, in MY PRIVATE place...All here are welcomed and in fact, encouraged to do the same.

Oh...and just for the record...I'm a man who is DEDICATED to making this world a more loving place and a place where we all can grow and love one another. Truly I am. That said...just TRY and burn MY flag...get it?

Peace...
Wow...how did I even get up ON that soap box, son? I love you.
Dad

alisaterry said...

Well...you won't like my answer. I think soluting the flag is akin to idolatry. I think the pledge is creepy. But I'm conflicted about this because they solute the flag in Boy Scouts and that is pretty much the entire boy's and young men's program in the Church, so obiously the pledge is benign.

I can see why some people don't respect the flag or the pledge or the national anthem, though, especially now while our country is being run by total idiots and I really don't pledge an allegiance to Bush.

For me, I'm not going to teach Connor NOT to do those things, but I'm not going to teach him to do them, either. If it is something he does as a scout, I support that.

Sea Guy said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Sea Guy said...

Dad,

Got off on an interesting tangent there... ;)

As far as a national language, I couldn't disagree with you more. In many countries in Eurasia, children are required to learn multiple languages growing up. Government services may be offered in more than one language. It is also interesting to note that the United States has never had an official language, merely a prevalent language. Improved communication begets respect. I will teach my children at least two languages, and we'll probably learn more together.

I think we, who are so rich, should bend quite a bit to meet others who are far less fortunate where they are. We have time to learn another language. They may not (working too much for too little, sacrificing much to send most of that back to their families in their home countries). You speak another language, and thus find the difficulties associated with that. That should engender compassion, not pride of "Well, I learned Spanish, so they should learn English." No, that's not well-educated. That's prideful and damning. I always think of you so far left, it surprises me when you jump out of the right field! Ah, the misconceptions I have about people...

As far as our traditions go, I think we get more harm from the ACLU than our foreign visiting neighbors. And I think that Christmas is completely robbed of its power in the current commercial paradigm. I am torn on the issue of the Christmas tree in the airport though...

Sea Guy said...

Alisa, I don't dislike your answer. I just don't agree. :) And, wow! You covered a lot of territory in a few words - I wish I could write that well.

I think that seeing soluting the flag as idolatry misses the point of the flag - it's not about the flag itself. The flag is merely a symbol for the nation.

As far as the pledge of allegiance, it is not so much to the cloth as to the nation, and the nation is most certainly not about the people in government office. Even if I say the pledge of allegiance, I am not pledging allegiance to the Texan in Washington, but to my country, to my neighbors, and recognizing the hand of God in the creation and maintenance of this nation.

Now to be fair about the YM program, BSA is supposed to be part of that program, not the entire thing, and during my years in YM, we met as scouts twice a month (three if we went camping).

I think that the national anthem itself is a beautiful description of the war of independence, a plea to always exemplify the virtues of of our forefathers who founded this country with blood and tears. To think it is about the current state of affairs misses the point. Read the lyrics again, and think of what Key was pleading for after his heart soared to see the symbol of that for which they were fighting still waving. It is really quite breath-taking.

In short, I don't think we should be fair-weather fans of our country; that said, I am completely a fair-weather fan of our nation's policies.

Tommy Dee said...

I guess I still (as eloquent as I sometimes think myself to be) do not explain myself well or clearly enough sometimes.
I am anything BUT a right-winger (Rush Limbaugh scares me to death-- only in that some actually take him seriously).
But...just as most Mexicans (just using them as my most well acquainted example) are FIERCELY proud of their national heritage, I am equally fiercely proud of mine. And son, while you have a GREAT deal more open-mindedness than peers in both our generations, the FACT is, that prior to, oh say the last 25 years or so...this nation never had an "official language" because it was simply a foregone conclusion that English WAS, in fact, that. Which is why, when my ancestors (and so many others like them) came here in the late 19th and early 20th century to escape the tyranny and insanity that was becoming Germany...they came here humble...and EAGER to assimilate with, rather than differ from, their new American "peers". It was a difficult job, because we the priviledged in this country so quickly forget the prices WE (or our very recent ancestors to be more correct) had to pay, and make it VERY hard on newcomers a lot of the time. I STILL believe everything I said previously, but to expand a bit... YES! They should learn English!!! And YES!!! I think it IS incumbent upon US to help them (incoming immigrant American's-to-be) find the fastest and most effective and LEAST painful ways to achieve that assimilation into AMERICAN culture.
I very much LOVE the fact that other countries are so rich in flavor and custom and tradition. But...so in fact, are WE the AMERICAN people.
In answer to your statement about my learning another language, I would agree with you actually...except for one very sad fact. We "who are so rich" as you said it... live in a nation that in my youth had over 90% literacy... and now has less than 79% literacy nationwide. The average high school graduate in America now reads at an amazing (amazing only in the shame of it) 9th grade reading level.

Talk about going on a slightly convoluted tangent...but all this truly DOES tie into "Patriotism and Respect" I believe. The sad fact is that Alisa's very well-stated position is very natural for her to have, I think...given the importance played on patriotism in our country today.
My heart breaks nearly in two as I see how harsh we have become in this nation to one another of us already here...much less to newcomers. So you see... I'm kind of torn myself.

(and I can almost hear it... "gee, where in HECK did all THAT come from Dad?" Just my confused and at times sad for our nation heart.)

You see... I struggle greatly with pride for what we WERE...and terribly dark sadness for what I'm afraid I see us becoming.